Most marketers obsess over subject lines, but it’s the email body that either seals the deal or sends your efforts into the trash bin.
So, let’s cut to the chase: You’ve managed to get someone to open your email. Kudos! But what happens next is even more critical. If your subject line is the “come-hither” glance, then your email body is the conversation that follows — and we all know first impressions can be make-or-break.
Throughout my 20 years in digital marketing, including a decade of leading marketing strategies at Dream Media, I’ve realized that emails are no less than a dialogue between a brand and its audience. The irony? While most marketers lose sleep over subject lines, they often disregard the email body, which is where the real conversion happens. Take it from me; I’ve seen brands double their conversion rates simply by A/B testing different body copies and employing consumer psychology.
For those of you keen on diving deep into the mechanics of email bodies, check out this comprehensive article that breaks down the Importance of Email Body Copy in Marketing.
Setting The Stage: Understanding Audience Psychology
Forget what you’ve heard—manipulation is not a dirty word in marketing. It’s the essence of understanding human psychology to create content that converts.
When you understand the underlying motivations and behavioral triggers that drive your audience, you’re not just shooting in the dark. You’re a sniper, aiming precisely at the bullseye of consumer intent.
Ann Handley, a notable marketing expert, once said, “Good content always has an objective; it’s created with intent. It, therefore, carries triggers to action.” In my early years at Diener Consultants, we were working on a political campaign. The emails weren’t garnering engagement until we started incorporating psychological triggers like ‘urgency’ and ‘social proof.’ Within weeks, donations skyrocketed, and the campaign gained massive traction.
From my two decades of experience in digital marketing, particularly in sectors such as E-commerce and SaaS, I’ve observed that grasping audience psychology is akin to possessing the keys to the kingdom. The better you understand what makes your customers tick, the more you can tailor your email body copy to nudge them in the direction you want.
For those wanting to delve into audience psychology, platforms like Crazy Egg provide insightful heat maps that reveal where users are most engaged in your emails. Additionally, SurveyMonkey can help you gauge your audience’s thoughts and preferences directly.
To read more about the importance of understanding audience psychology in marketing, I recommend this study from the Journal of Consumer Psychology. Or read here: Mastering the Psychology of Decision-making: Strategies for Successful Business Strategy
Crafting the Perfect Opening
The first sentence of your email is the handshake of the digital world — and you wouldn’t offer a limp handshake in a business meeting, would you?
Look, you’ve got milliseconds to make an impression in an inbox full of competing messages. A compelling opening sets the stage, gripping your reader and encouraging them to stick around for the encore.
Seth Godin, the marketing guru, astutely remarked, “Marketing is no longer about the stuff you make but the stories you tell.” I’ll never forget a project with a high-profile E-commerce client in my Dream Media days. We saw a 30% uptick in click-through rates just by rephrasing the opening line of our emails. That’s the power of storytelling wedded to a killer opening sentence.
Drawing from my extensive B2B content marketing for tech companies, I can’t stress enough how crucial that opening line is. It’s not just about being flashy; it’s about establishing immediate relevance and value. I’ve often advised my team to spend as much time on the first sentence as they do on the subject line. Why? Because an intriguing subject line gets your email opened, but a magnetic opening keeps the reader engaged.
If you’re unsure about your opening lines, platforms like Coschedule’s Email Subject Line Tester can provide some insights, despite being designed for subject lines. It evaluates the emotional impact of your sentences, which is invaluable for openings as well. For A/B testing those opening lines, Mailchimp is a great resource.
To further investigate the science behind compelling openings, consider this insightful article from HubSpot on Crafting the Perfect Opening Lines.
The Narrative Arc: Structuring Your Email Body
In the realm of emails, consider the body your stage. Your characters, plot, and climax should play out here in a way that not only entertains but sells.
Here’s the deal: Humans are hardwired to love stories. This isn’t kindergarten show-and-tell; it’s about weaving a narrative that speaks to your audience’s needs and propels them to action.
Joe Pulizzi, the founder of Content Marketing Institute, once said, “Content is the atomic particle of all digital marketing.” A B2B tech client I worked with illustrates this beautifully. They were struggling with a complex product offering. Once we switched from feature lists to storytelling in the email body, focusing on customer pain points and solutions, lead engagement soared by 40%.
From my work across sectors like sports betting, real estate tech, and online dating at Dream Media, it’s clear that no one-size-fits-all template can serve the unique needs of diverse industries. However, the narrative arc remains universal. It provides a structured, relatable format for your message that can be tailored to any target audience.
To help you frame your email body, tools like Hemingway App can ensure your content is readable and engaging. Moreover, for streamlining this process, Campaign Monitor has a feature that allows you to easily input and format your story-based email content.
For a deeper dive into narrative techniques in email marketing, check out this article by Content Marketing Institute on Structuring Email for Engagement.
Using Calls-to-Action Wisely
A great email without a call-to-action (CTA) is like a blockbuster movie with no ending — it leaves you hanging, unsatisfied, and you eventually forget about it.
Listen up; CTAs aren’t just the “click here” or “buy now” buttons we casually throw at the end of an email. They are the crescendo in your symphony, the climax in your story, the point where your audience decides to take action or just walk away.
Neil Patel, a leading voice in digital marketing, stated, “Without a call-to-action, you are wasting your best efforts and goodwill on readers who probably would take action if told to do so.” In my years at Dream Media, one client in the online dating sector increased user engagement by 70% simply by revamping their CTAs to be more aligned with user psychology. They went from generic phrases like “Find Love” to specific cues like “Start Your Love Journey Today.”
When I led a team focused on SaaS marketing, we found that CTAs work best when they’re not just clear but also relatable. For example, instead of using a generic “Learn More,” we tested out phrases like “Unlock Your Full Potential.” This pivot saw a 20% increase in click-through rates because we touched on an emotional level that resonates with the customer.
To create and A/B test your CTAs, I’d recommend using Unbounce. Their platform allows for robust CTA testing and optimization. For tracking CTA performance, Kissmetrics provides deep analytics to understand how your audience interacts with your CTAs.
If you want to see how CTAs are evolving and what trends are capturing attention, take a look at this article on Innovative CTA Strategies.
When to Use Visuals
In the digital age, an email without visuals is like a rock concert without a light show—sure, the message may get across, but you’re missing out on an unforgettable experience.
Alright, let’s talk visuals. Adding images, GIFs, or even video content in your emails isn’t just an aesthetic choice; it’s a strategic move that can significantly increase user engagement and conversion rates.
Ann Handley, the Chief Content Officer of MarketingProfs, aptly stated, “In a world where we are flooded with words, visuals help your email stand out.” I recall a B2B tech client that switched from text-heavy emails to incorporating infographics. Their open rates went from 15% to an astonishing 40%.
One of my most successful campaigns at Dream Media was for a SaaS client in the real estate tech sector. We added simple yet elegant property photos alongside text descriptions in their newsletters. This simple change resulted in a 30% increase in client inquiries.
When it comes to sourcing high-quality visuals, I recommend platforms like Unsplash for free, high-quality images. To optimize and size your visuals, you can use a tool like TinyPNG. For creating eye-catching infographics or video content, Canva is a go-to choice.
For those keen on understanding the psychology behind using visuals in email marketing, don’t miss this comprehensive guide on The Science of Color in Marketing: How to Use Color Psychology to Boost Your Brand.
Trust Elements and Social Proof
In the realm of email marketing, trust isn’t just a bonus; it’s the currency. Without it, your emails are mere white noise.
Imagine you’re in a coffee shop, and someone you’ve never met starts giving you investment advice. Would you trust them immediately? Probably not. The same principle applies to email marketing. You’re in someone’s personal space—their inbox—so how do you establish trust right off the bat?
Jay Baer, a renowned marketing consultant, emphasizes, “If your stories are all about your products and services, that’s not storytelling. It’s a brochure. Give yourself permission to make the story bigger.” One of my most fascinating projects was for a sports betting platform. We included testimonials from previous big winners and even integrated real-time odds into the email. It wasn’t just promotional; it was social proof in action.
During my time as Digital Marketing Director at Dream Media, we worked with a nonprofit organization. They struggled to convert their email recipients into donors. We included real-life testimonials and success stories, transforming their conversion rates from a meager 2% to a stunning 19%.
To collect and manage testimonials and reviews effectively, consider using platforms like Trustpilot or Yotpo. For embedding social proof elements like real-time counters or trending items, ProveSource is a highly effective tool.
If you want to delve deeper into the psychology of social proof, check out this insightful article The Power of Social Proof in Marketing: How to Leverage Reviews and Testimonials for Success.
Closing with Impact
Sending an email without a strong closing is like leaving the stage without a bow—yes, you delivered, but you missed the chance for a lasting impression.
Let’s face it; the closing of your email is your final opportunity to leave an indelible mark on your reader. Think of it as the climax of a great movie or the crescendo of a musical masterpiece.
Seth Godin, a marketing maven, once said, “The only purpose of ‘customer service’… is to change feelings.” I can’t stress enough how many times a well-placed call-to-action or a heartfelt ‘thank you’ has turned potential customers into lifelong clients in my years of consulting.
One specific project at Diener Consultants involved an e-commerce client that had an issue with shopping cart abandonment. We implemented a compelling CTA in the closing section of their retargeting emails, followed by a limited-time discount offer. This simple tweak saw a 25% reduction in cart abandonment rates.
If you want to add eye-catching CTAs to your emails, tools like OptinMonster or ConvertFlow are worth considering. For those interested in including a survey or feedback form at the end of your emails, Typeform is an excellent option.
For an extended discussion on crafting impactful email closings, I recommend this detailed guide on How to End an Email: Tips and Examples for Signing Off.
Conclusion
The ability to craft email body copy that resonates with your audience is not just an art; it’s a science that you can master. From understanding your audience’s psychology to knowing when to use visuals, each element plays a critical role in your overall email marketing strategy.
Calls to Action in Conclusion:
- If you’re overwhelmed with crafting the perfect email campaigns, don’t hesitate to reach out for professional assistance. I offer comprehensive Email Marketing Services that can help you boost engagement and ROI. Contact me today to take your email marketing to the next level.
- For more insights and updates, don’t forget to subscribe to my newsletter on LinkedIn or Medium.
Additional Resources
1. Tools and Platforms:
- OptinMonster for creating compelling CTAs.
- Typeform for including surveys or feedback forms in your emails.
- Payoneer: For streamlining your payment processes especially if you work with international clients.
2. Recommended Reading:
3. Charles Lange Consulting Services: For those who are looking for a more comprehensive approach to their digital strategy, here are some services that could benefit you:
This concludes our comprehensive guide on crafting email body copy that converts. Thank you for staying with us until the end. Your success in email marketing is just an email away!
Marketing Unplugged 
Leave a Reply